Why are so many retail stores closing in 2023?

Why are so many retail stores closing in 2023?


Its about crime, liberal lack of policing and, well, crime!

The question of why big box stores find it difficult to operate in liberal cities is complex and involves several interconnected factors. While it’s important not to make blanket generalizations about “liberal cities,” it’s worth noting that several such cities have seen debates around crime rates, theft prevention, and law enforcement practices. However, these are not the only issues at play; zoning laws, local politics, and social attitudes also come into the picture. This essay aims to delve into these issues, particularly focusing on the challenges related to crime enforcement.

Law Enforcement and Crime Rates

In some liberal cities, there have been discussions around defunding the police or reallocating resources to social services. While the intentions may be aimed at social reform, critics argue that these actions can sometimes lead to a less effective police presence. The impact of these policies on crime rates is still a matter of debate, but for big box stores concerned about theft and vandalism, the perception of reduced law enforcement can be a deterrent.

Theft Prevention

Big box stores, given their large footprints and high volume of merchandise, are often prime targets for shoplifting and organized retail crime. The absence of robust law enforcement support can make loss prevention a significant challenge. Private security can help but is often not enough to completely prevent theft or to make the store’s operations economically viable. Advanced surveillance technology might assist but also comes with high costs and privacy concerns.

Zoning Laws and Local Politics

Beyond issues of crime and law enforcement, liberal cities often have strict zoning laws that can make it difficult for big box stores to find suitable locations. Community boards and local politicians may also be less inclined to welcome these stores, fearing they will displace local businesses and change the character of the neighborhood.

Social Attitudes

Public opinion in liberal cities may also be less favorable towards big box retailers, often seen as symbols of corporate America. Instead, there is usually a strong support for local businesses, which are considered to contribute more authentically to the community.

Economic Factors

The higher cost of living and higher minimum wage laws in some liberal cities can also make it more expensive for big box stores to operate. Employee costs, property rents, and other operational expenses are generally elevated, requiring a more substantial volume of sales to break even, which is risky in an environment where theft is a significant concern.


While it’s not universally true that big box stores can’t operate in liberal cities, they do face a unique set of challenges. Reduced law enforcement resources and evolving attitudes towards crime prevention can indeed make theft a significant concern. However, this is only one piece of a larger puzzle that includes local politics, zoning laws, social attitudes, and economic factors. Each of these elements plays a role in shaping the retail landscape of liberal cities, complicating the operational dynamics for big box stores.

Why are so many retail stores closing in 2023? Why are so many retail stores closing in 2023?

Stores Closing Include Amazon, Walmart, and Bed Bath & Beyond in 2023 (businessinsider.com)

The real reasons stores are closing in big cities | CNN Business