Was the P-51 Mustang the Best Fighter in WW2?

Was the P-51 Mustang the Best Fighter in WW2?

World War 2

“Aviation is proof that given, the will, we have the capacity to achieve the impossible.”

-Eddie Rickenbacker
P-51’s flying above the USS Texas

The sleek P-51 Mustang is perhaps the best all-around fighter of World War II. In 1939, British officials approached North American Aviation in desperate need of additional aircraft for the war in Europe. Just 117 days after the order was placed, the first P-51 was rolled out of the factory.

P-51D on the Inglewood assembly line

The P-51 Mustang was a highly capable fighter aircraft that played a significant role in Allied victory during World War II. It was particularly effective in the European theater of operations, where it was used for escort missions and for attacking enemy ground targets.

A pilot selected to fly the P-51 Mustang would typically have undergone several months of training before being deemed proficient in the aircraft. This would have included both ground school training, where pilots learned the principles of flight and aircraft systems, as well as flight training, where they practiced flying the Mustang under the supervision of an instructor.

Flying a fighter aircraft such as the P-51 Mustang required a high level of skill and proficiency.
A Royal Air Force North American Mustang Mk III (FX908) on the ground at Hucknall

The Mustang’s long range and high speed made it a formidable opponent in air-to-air combat, and its excellent handling characteristics made it popular with pilots.

The P-51 Mustang did play a significant role in the protection of Allied bombers during World War II, particularly the B-17 Flying Fortress. 

The presence of P-51 escorts significantly improved the safety of B-17s on bombing missions, as it reduced the threat from enemy fighters and made it more difficult for them to attack the bombers.

The B-17 was an important strategic bomber that was used by the United States Army Air Forces (USAAF) to carry out long-range bombing missions deep into enemy territory. However, the B-17 was vulnerable to attack by enemy fighters, and it relied on escorts to protect it from enemy aircraft. The P-51 Mustang was one of the primary fighters used to escort B-17s on their bombing missions. The Mustang was particularly effective in this role due to its long range and high speed.

For further reading see our piece: What Caused The B-17 To Crash?
Medal of Honor recipient Lt. Col. James H. Howard, in the cockpit of his P-51 Mustang

However, it is worth noting that flying bombing missions was still a very dangerous and risky endeavor. Furthermore, the B-17s and their crews became exposed to many other hazards, such as anti-aircraft fire and mechanical issues. Despite the improved protection provided by the P-51 escorts, B-17s and their crews continued to suffer heavy losses during the war.

The Mustang was able to keep up with the B-17s and provide them with protection from enemy fighters, helping to ensure their safety and effectiveness on bombing missions. The P-51’s ability to escort the B-17s played a key role in the Allied strategic bombing campaign of World War II, and it helped to turn the tide of the war in favor of the Allies.

A Long Range

P-51 Mustangs of the 375th Fighter Squadron, Eighth Air Force mid-1944

The Mustang was designed to have a long range, which made it particularly effective for escort missions and for attacking enemy ground targets. It was able to fly long distances without the need for refueling, which allowed it to accompany bombers on their missions deep into enemy territory.

High Speeds

The Mustang was one of the fastest fighters of its time, and its excellent performance at high altitudes made it a formidable opponent in air-to-air combat.

Excellent Handling

The Mustang became known for its excellent handling characteristics, which made it popular with pilots. Its responsive controls and stable flight made it easy to fly and maneuver, even at high speeds.

Impressive Versatility

A USAAF armorer of the 100th Fighter Squadron. 332nd Fighter Group. 15th U.S. Air Force checks ammunition belts of the .50 caliber (12.7 mm) Browning machine guns in the wings of a North American P-51B Mustang in Italy, circa September 1944

The Mustang was a versatile aircraft that was able to perform a variety of missions, including air-to-air combat, air-to-ground attack, and escort. Its ability to excel in multiple roles made it an invaluable asset to the Allied war effort.

On December 25, 1944, George E. Preddy Jr., the top P-51 Mustang ace during World War II, was shot down by friendly ground fire during the battle of the Bulge. A huge loss for the eight air force, Preddy became famous as a result of just 4 months after receiving his first P-52 , in August of 1944. George would shoot down 6 German planes in one day! 

Top-scoring Mustang ace of WWII, Major George Earl Preddy Jr. with 26.83 aerial victories and five aircraft destroyed on the ground (first three victories were achieved on P-47)

As a result, earned himself a Distinguished Service Cross—the nation’s second highest award—in the process.

Preddy was shot down during the Battle of the Bulge while flying in his plane, the Cripes A’Mighty, in pursuit of a German plane. He is buried at the Lorraine American Cemetery in France.

The cost of a P-51D model, which was the most widely produced version of the aircraft, was around $51,000 in 1944 dollars. 
P-51D 44-14888 of the 8th AF/357th FG/363rd FS, named Glamorous Glen III, is the aircraft in which Chuck Yeager achieved most of his 12.5 kills, including two Me 262s – shown here with twin single-use 108-gallon (409-l) drop tanks fitted. Moreover, this aircraft was renamed “Melody’s Answer” In addition, crashed on Mar 2, 1945, from unknown causes at Haseloff, west of Treuenbrietzen, Germany.…

This would be equivalent to around $810,000 in 2021 dollars, using the Consumer Price Index as a measure of inflation. 

However, it is worth noting that the cost of producing an aircraft includes many other factors beyond the raw materials and labor, such as research and development, testing, and overhead costs, which can significantly impact the final price of the aircraft.

In conclusion, there were many other excellent fighters produced during the war, such as the Spitfire, the Focke-Wulf Fw 190, and lastly the Japanese Zero, that also made significant contributions to the war effort. In addition, were highly respected by their pilots.

North American NA-73X, with a short carburetor air intake scoop and the frameless, rounded windshield: On the production Mustang Mk Is, the frameless windshield was replaced with a three-piece unit that incorporated a bullet-resistant windshield.

Was the P-51 Mustang the Best Fighter in WW2?

World War 2