Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.

is arXiv Peer Reviewed?

is arXiv Peer Reviewed?

Science News

undefined

In the engineering community, the use of arXiv, a repository for electronic preprints, recently emerged as a topic of debate among many an academic. Moreover, particularly regarding its credibility due to the lack of a peer review.

Furthermore, this concern manifests in the personal experiences of many engineers and academics, who often find themselves advised against citing arXiv papers.

However, a closer examination of arXiv’s role in disseminating research reveals a more sensitive understanding of its value and limitations.

Understanding Peer Review and arXiv’s Position

undefined
The logo of arXiv – online digital archive for electronic preprints of scientific papers. Image credit: Shamsi Beers Brinn – https://info.arxiv.org/brand/logos.html

Traditionally, peer review acted as the hallmark of scientific quality and rigor. Involving the evaluation of research by experts in the field before publication in a journal. However, arXiv, on the other hand, hosts preprints, which are versions of scientific papers that precede formal peer review. As a result, often leading to skepticism about the reliability of the research presented on arXiv.

In engineering, where applied research is predominant, there’s a noticeable absence of arXiv citations. Partly because arXiv papers tend to be more theoretical and ‘mathy’, which may not align with the more practical nature of typical engineering work. As a result, engineers might find themselves less exposed to or reliant on arXiv for their research needs.

The Role of Established Researchers on arXiv

Image of Steven Strogatz

Professor Steven Strogatz | Cornell Department of Mathematics

Notably, some prominent researchers in fields like nonlinear dynamical systems, such as Steven Strogatz and John Baez, have been active contributors to arXiv. This suggests that arXiv is not just a repository for work that couldn’t find a home elsewhere but is also a platform for established academics seeking a broader audience or for those who wish to disseminate their findings more rapidly than the traditional publishing route allows.

Professor John Baez : University of Edinburgh

The decision to submit to arXiv varies!

For some, it’s a way to quickly disseminate findings and get feedback while waiting for peer review in traditional journals. For others, especially those working in rapidly evolving fields, arXiv serves as a medium to access the most current research, which may not yet be available in journals due to the slower peer review process.

Many researchers use arXiv to share preprints of their work that are simultaneously undergoing the peer review process for journal publication. This approach helps in gaining immediate visibility and feedback, potentially accelerating the advancement of the field.

Evaluating Research: Beyond the Peer Review Paradigm

undefined
Website interface by Arxiv; paper abstract copyright Priedhorsky et al. – https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.03677

The key takeaway for engineering professionals and researchers is that the value of a research paper should not be judged solely based on whether it has undergone peer review.

Instead, each paper, whether from arXiv or a peer-reviewed journal, should become critically evaluated on its own merits. Peer review is not an infallible guarantee of quality, and similarly, papers on arXiv should not stand dismissed outright due to their non-peer-reviewed status.

In conclusion, while arXiv differs from traditional journals in terms of its review process, it plays a crucial role in the rapid dissemination of research, especially in fast-evolving fields.

Thus, its growing use by established researchers is a testament to its value in the academic community. For engineers and scientists, understanding the motivations behind using arXiv and adopting a discerning approach to evaluating research, regardless of its source, essential in today’s fast-paced research environment.

is arXiv Peer Reviewed?