From Prototype Machining to Scalable Manufacturing: WayKen’s Approach to Production Consistency
To get from first-article approval to repeat production of a custom component, it is not enough to simply demonstrate that the component meets the drawing specifications. The approved component sets out the baseline for manufacturing and should be replicated through revisions, datums, fixturing, programming, tooling, and inspection. In terms of CNC machined parts, maintaining this information makes it less likely that variations will arise from batch to batch and that operators will have to recreate the process by relying on memory.
First Article Approval Establishes the Production Baseline
First article inspection should document what is in place when a part has been approved. The drawing revision must specify all the parameters such as dimensions, tolerancing, materials, finish, etc. required by the part. The datum reference frame for machining must correspond to the functional references in the drawing; the fixtures must position the work piece relative to these references. Documentation of the setup sequence is also necessary, since altering the sequence of roughing, repositioning and finishing will alter the cumulative error.
The manufacturing record should correlate the approved revision with its CAM program, the machine setup, cutting tools, tool numbers, and tool offsets. If there is a change in a cutter diameter, insert, or offset it should be evaluated whether it affects a critical feature. WayKen’s production processes demonstrate this correlation: the fixturing, machining operations, and inspection processes are coordinated such that critical dimensions are compared to the anticipated process prior to beginning repeated production. Thus CNC machined parts have a defined baseline for production rather than being produced based on the first “acceptable” unit.
Repeatability Depends on Controlling the Manufacturing Process
The repeat production process relies upon controlling variables as opposed to fixing defects once they are produced. A number of factors including fixture wear, varying clamping methods, cutting tool wear, temperature variations and improper programming will cause dimensional variations to occur over time, even though the exact same CAM program has been utilized. For this reason, the setup plan must include specification of datum locations, work-holding, the order of machining and which finishing processes are used.
Operators conducting in-process inspections should focus on those features that tend to vary the most or have the greatest effect on assembly. Inspection of the most sensitive holes, position accuracy of holes, and dimension verification of key reference surfaces at various points throughout the production process provides operators with insight into potential variations prior to completing all components of a batch.
In addition to verifying finished product dimensions, WayKen utilizes in-process inspections to assess the consistency of their products by monitoring machining operations relative to measuring conditions versus solely inspecting completed products. This approach is particularly relevant to precision machined parts in a production environment where a slight dimensional or positional shift could negatively impact mating surfaces’ fit and seal characteristics and subsequent assembly steps.
Production Records Keep Later Batches Consistent
The repeat-order record will contain all elements that were previously approved for production like drawing revisions, materials, fixtures used to position the part on the table, setup sequences, CAM revisions, cutting tools, offsets used to position features relative to other features, inspection points to measure critical dimensions, measured results, and accepted/denied status. This information is what allows a subsequent production batch to replicate a validated process rather than rely upon the assumptions made at the beginning of the next process run.
Reports generated during each stage of production are recorded in conjunction with the measurement data collected throughout each process. Comparing these historical dimensional trend records provides insight into whether or not there has been any deviation in a repeated feature. If this occurs, reviewing previous measurement records may provide evidence as to whether tool wear, fixture position changes, machine variations, or some type of design change occurred.
Traceable production records also aid in identifying the version of process that created a specific batch of CNC-machined parts. WayKen’s production and quality control processes demonstrate the benefit of associating first article inspection reports, in-process checks, and final inspection reports. By keeping these records associated, they create a “manufacturing history” of the product. When a repeat order comes in months after initial production, this “history” eliminates much of the uncertainty associated with returning to the original approved precision machined parts process.
Conclusion
Transitioning from the first article to production involves preserving the manufacturing environment in which the first article was approved. Revision drawings, datums, fixturing, CAM files, tooling, offsets, measurement points, and final records must all stay linked in the production process. If these controls are kept intact, precision-machined parts will have increased consistency in their manufacturing, and changes can be assessed and acted upon without impacting subsequent production runs.



