Culloden Battle : British Civil War? Or Scotland’s Civil War?
Culloden Battle : British Civil War? Or Scotland’s Civil War? In 1745, a group called the Jacobites, led by Charles Stuart, formed a rebellion against the British throne in an attempt to restore power to the previous king, James Francis Edward Stuart. (pictured below) The Jacobites believed in the divine right of kings.
And since James Stuart had lost his throne in an illegitimate fashion in their eyes. The Jacobites maintained that the current king, George II, was illegitimate. (pictured below)
The Jacobite uprising battled a force of 12,000 British government soldiers, who were, at the time, the most decorated infantrymen of Europe. George II’s son, the Duke of Cumberland would lead the government force.
The Jacobite army mostly consisted of Gaelic-speaking Catholic Scottish Highlanders, but also included some English, Irish, and French troops.
Most of these men had poor training, and were ‘uncontrollable’ and ‘inexperienced’. To add to the plight of the Jacobites. Supplies were scarce. Which left men only with a broadsword, shield, and pistol for arms. Later in the uprising, however, supplies from France equipped Jacobite troops with improved firelocks.
The opposing government army was in much better shape. Many of the British soldiers facing the rebellion were pulled back from the ongoing War of Austrian Succession. And had become battle-hardened and experienced. The British army’s intense drilling and training made their soldiers extremely effective and deadly with the musket.
At the battle of Culloden, the government army consisted of 16 battalions, 11 British, 4 Scottish(mostly from the Scottish Lowlands, but actually outnumbered the total Scottish Highlander’s on the Jacobite side), and 1 Irish. The government army’s weapons included 3-pound artillery pieces, cable of firing round iron and canister shot.
The night before the battle, the British handed out 2 gallons of brandy per regiment to celebrate the Duke of Cumberland’s birthday.
This occasion seemed like an ideal time for a night raid against the partying British soldiers. Nearly 1,500 Jacobites assembled. But this attack was called off at the last minute. Because the war council felt that there would not be enough time to attack before dawn. By the time the troops made it back to the estate at Culloden. Many were tired and looking for food or rest and subsequently missed the battle.
The Battle of Culloden took place on 16 April 1746. And commenced with a small artillery fire by the Jacobite army, which was reciprocated by artillery fire from the government army.
The Jacobite army suffered minor casualties as a result of the shelling.
At roughly 1 pm, the Jacobites began to advance towards the government line, directly into the round iron fire of artillery. When the Jacobites were 300 meters away from the government line, government artillery switched ordinance to canister shot, a type of artillery ammunition composed of a canister full of musket shot, effectively turning each artillery piece into a massive shotgun.
As the need for precise aim is unnecessary for a canister shot. The rate of artillery fire into the charging Jacobite forces rapidly increased.
This resulted in devastating casualties for the advancing force. Furthermore, the Scottish Highlander’s relied upon charging as their main offensive maneuver, a tactic made difficult by the soft terrain of Culloden Moor.
Within 50 meters British infantry men, which were organized in three lines, began to fire their muskets. Due to their formation, a volley of musket fire was let off every six seconds. But despite this impressive firepower the Jacobite army continued to advance.
Once in range, the Jacobite army pulled out their firearms, fired a single volley.
And drew their swords to close the rest of the distance between them and the government army.
The government troops were all armed with a bayonet on their firearms, and the subsequent hand-to-hand was bloody and brutal. The highlander charge happend to hit the government left wing especially hard. This resulted in a slight cave in of the government line.
This ended up being a tactical disaster for the Jacobites attacking the left wing. As a result, government regiments on either side of the cave-in were able to open fire at the attackers from three different directions.
As the attack on the left wing became crushed by the experienced British soldiers. The Jacobites started to retreat. But it quickly devolved into a rout as government forces gunned down the fleeing Jacobites.
At the end of the day the British cavalry was a key imbalance in the battle. Maybe even more so than firepower, which is also why the ensuing pursuit was so deadly.
The result of the Battle of Culloden was a convincing government victory. And brought a swift end to the Jacobite uprising of 1745. The Jacobites suffered tremendous casualties. Totaling roughly 2,000 men killed or wounded as opposed to the 300 killed or wounded on the government side. Of the more than 1,000 Jacobite soldiers killed, only 1/5th were carrying a sword. The British lost only 46 men and had fewer than 300 wounded.
In conclusion, life in the Scottish highlands would never be the same. The British essentially extinguished traditional Scottish Clan life. Furthermore, the British took away any legal power the rulers of the Clans had once enjoyed. In addition, hundreds of years of traditions ended. And the British spent years brutally fighting off the last of the Scottish Jacobites.